With under 80 days to the midterms, Chuck Todd and Chris Cillizza pause the horse race for a full "where are we now" audit of the 2028 Democratic field — prompted, Chris admits, by listener pushback that they'd been too dismissive of Gavin Newsom. Using the Kalshi and Polymarket odds as a starting point rather than gospel, they work through a top tier of AOC, Newsom, and Jon Ossoff. Chuck's central thesis is that AOC could become a magnetic force on the scale of Trump in 2016 or Obama in 2008 — a candidacy the entire field gets measured against, potentially freezing out half the governors and senators eyeing a run. He maps how she could be the frontrunner while playing underdog in South Carolina, and why the new calendar's crowded first state may actually cushion her. On Newsom, Chuck is blunt: the prediction markets are artificially inflating him, the attention economy is doing the work, and a California governor with a mixed record has no obvious state to win. They also make the case that Kamala Harris ultimately doesn't run — and that not running is the smarter play for 2032.
The back half turns to the field's second tier and its long shots: whether Mark Kelly has the hunger and the issue to go with the biography (Chuck's dream ticket: Kelly and Warnock, order randomized), why John Glenn and Bill Bradley are the cautionary tales for résumé candidates, whether Ossoff can realistically jump straight from an $87 million Senate race into a billion-dollar presidential campaign, and a genuine dark-horse case for Rahm Emanuel built on the party's underinvestment in rural Black voters. They preview Tuesday's Florida primary — Byron Donalds's real ceiling, why Chuck thinks the general could land inside five points, the Mel Martinez precedent, and Corey Mills, Debbie Wasserman Schultz, and Alex Vindman. Then the tone shifts hard: an angry, unsparing exchange about the expired US-Iran memorandum, the Strait of Hormuz, conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, and Pete Hegseth's fitness for the job.
Timeline:
(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)
00:00 Under 80 days out — and a full 2028 Democratic audit
01:06 Why Chuck thinks JD Vance will divide the right
02:08 The prediction markets as one data point, not the whole story
02:55 Reading Polymarket and Kalshi: AOC, Newsom, Ossoff at the top
05:12 Could AOC suck up all the oxygen the way Trump did in '16?
06:15 The egg-freezing story as proof of her magnetic pull
06:42 Skeptical Newsom can play in Michigan, Iowa, South Carolina
07:30 The impossible position for Newsom
08:16 AOC's advantage — no long record to defend
09:38 Could egg-freezing access become an issue she champions?
10:01 How her presence could paralyze half the field before it starts
10:57 Where does that leave Pritzker? Or Ossoff?
11:59 The formalized DNC calendar
13:37 Nevada, Michigan and the Culinary Union question
14:42 Why a crowded South Carolina helps the progressive lane
15:13 What 2020 looked like when South Carolina came fourth
15:49 Newsom's real problem: where does he actually win?
16:59 Harris's East Coast headquarters lesson
17:22 Advice: put your HQ in Michigan, not San Francisco
19:42 The counterargument: no gatekeepers left, and the hustler wins
20:10 Ossoff, Buttigieg & who's actually willing to burn the boats
21:08 Newsom one-on-one vs. Newsom in a big room
22:08 Would a swing-state Democrat invite Newsom to campaign?
23:04 Harris analysis: you don't buy in Malibu if you're running
24:06 The Dan Quayle risk if she runs under these circumstances
25:01 Newsom and Harris can't both run
26:20 Mark Kelly in Iowa & the quote that reads like a stump speech
27:15 Chuck's lab-built ticket: an astronaut and a pastor
27:50 Will the Democratic base accept Kelly?
29:30 Is Kelly too pro-business for this version of the party?
30:45 How Trump's attacks on Kelly may have helped him
31:33 The real gap: Kelly has no signature issue
32:03 AOC is the change candidate — inside the party and outside it
33:09 Biographies don't win the presidency
33:30 The cautionary tales: John Glenn and Bill Bradley
35:08 The charisma gap — and Kelly's habit of yelling to show energy
35:55 Scanning the long shots on the board
36:55 If not AOC, then Ro Khanna
37:16 Pritzker at 1% — the governor who could reach the left
37:46 Chuck's real dark horse: Rahm Emanuel
39:32 Democrats' rural problem isn't just rural whites
39:59 The left will never accept him
42:07 Not a cycle for an insider — but maybe for an ideas guy
42:27 The Wisconsin lesson: Crowley won against something
42:50 To Florida: Tuesday's primary and Tuesday night's live stream
43:35 Jolly-Donalds could land inside five points
44:01 Why Florida isn't as noncompetitive as people assume
44:44 Could DeSantis win a third term?
45:24 What's Donalds's real number?
46:16 The Mel Martinez precedent
48:29 Why Chuck thinks Jerry Demings had the better shot at Donalds
49:56 The 2018 what-if: Bernie, Soros, Gillum and DeSantis
50:43 Credit to DeSantis for saying what Trump never does
51:48 Debbie Wasserman Schultz in a majority-Black district
52:38 The Vindman question — and the residency problem
54:23 The US-Iran memorandum expires with no deal
55:46 A $1.5 trillion budget and a carrier crew that can't get fed
56:11 Testosterone tests and push-up contests while the Lincoln goes short
56:33 Operationally a disaster — and where's the audit?
57:57 Damaging the last institution still standing
59:51 The Nats get swept by the Mets
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
